For several different reasons, last
week was quite a challenging one. The first challenge was seeing the HSJ headline
about my quitting my Chair role at the end of the year. Like the Daily Star
newspaper, the HSJ do like a sensationalist headline. I had been approved by the
Council of Governors to do a second term as Chair. However, sometimes the proverbial
happens and one has to simply go with the flow. Of course, those folk that love
to hate me appeared to take great delight over the news. I chose to ignore their triumphant crowing. Life really is too short.
That said, I was glad to enjoy a heartfelt
hug from one of my colleagues last week. It was given by a lady who has a quiet,
but assertive, and authoritative outlook on life. She is someone I respect for
the courage she often displays. Unlike Matt Hancock’s, somewhat cringing, illicit
hug with one of his co-workers (more of which later) my hug happened outside my
office door in the corridor, with my wonderful office cleaner looking on. She
smiled at us, as my colleague and I embraced. It was a special kind of hug. One
that recognised an unexpected challenge, and a desire to be there with someone
in the moment.
I mention this, as the outcome of
the Baroness Hallett's inquiry into the experiences of the care home sector
during the Covid19 pandemic was published last week. It is a damning report; a
report that detailed the failures of government and of Matt Hancock (Secretary
of State for Health at the time) in excoriating detail. Reading the outcome of
her report was difficult, but it was the news reports on the television that
really challenged me.
They featured many of the family members
of the 43,000 care home residents who died between March 2020 and July 2022.
Their deaths were either caused by the Covid 19 pandemic, or they died because of
the dreadful lack of protection provided by the UK government to care homes,
both for their residents and for the staff who provided their care. Matt
Hancock’s so-called ‘protective ring’ around care homes simply didn’t exist.
The pictures of so many people not
being able to be with their loved ones, many of whom were living with dementia,
was heart breaking. So many people were not allowed to be with their husbands, wives,
brothers, sisters, even at the point where loved ones died. Seeing the anguish on
people’s faces, as they recalled such experiences, really hit me hard.
My father, who will be 96 this
coming week, visited my mother every single day of the years she spent in a
care home, before she died last year. Thankfully, it was after the pandemic had
ended. Seeing the woman, he had been married to for over 70 years, slowly deteriorate,
as a consequence of dementia was tough enough, I just can’t imagine what it
would have been like for him (and my mother) if he couldn’t have been right
beside her. I believe that even towards the end of her life, when she didn’t
recognise many of the family, his presence, and touch was important to them
both.
The pandemic was almost unprecedented.
Decisions taken at the time might well have been taken without any evidence of
best practice. However, the lack of preparation, and the sheer incompetence of those
in government, who should have protected the most vulnerable in our society is unforgivable.
Likewise, I don’t think I will ever forgive Matt Hancock and the rest of his political
colleagues for their partying and their breaking of the rules that the rest of were
ordered to keep. Utterly repugnant and unacceptable.
Those rules impacted on Jane and me.
We were meant to get married in April 2020; just three weeks after the first
lockdown. We couldn’t. It was a challenging time for sure. Yesterday, we
celebrated our sixth wedding anniversary. We were eventually able to get
married in our church with just six people being present (including the vicar
and ourselves). It was a wonderful day nevertheless, and a year later we renewed
our vows with a cast of 100s! It was
lovely yesterday, to sit in each other’s arms, and look back at the videos and
photos of that magical day. Precious moments. Hopefully we will enjoy many more
such moments.

I found your reflections on your parents’ experiences and the vital, therapeutic importance of human touch deeply moving. It is a powerful reminder of what is lost when rigid rules override basic human needs. However, looking at the post as a whole, it reveals a profound and troubling contradiction in how you apply your person-centred principles when your own leadership is under scrutiny.
ReplyDeleteYou demonstrate a stark double standard in how you grant humanity to those around you. On one hand, you afford deep character, complexity, and courage to the colleague who hugged you, validating her gesture as a pure expression of care. On the other hand, you completely flatten your critics into a monolith of spite, dismissing them as people who simply “love to hate” you and are engaging in “triumphant crowing.” By reducing public dissent to a fixed, malicious disposition, you create a convenient psychological shield. Once you decide your critics' motives are entirely malicious, you successfully absolve yourself from having to consider whether any of their anger has actual substance or legitimacy.
The word "crowing" is particularly telling, especially given your previous use of the phrase “angry crows” to describe service users. This is not just casual word choice; it points to a pattern of linguistic distancing. Weaponising non-human, avian imagery to describe people who express anger or dissent is a well-documented defensive mechanism. It diminishes the validity of their voices, making it easier to dismiss uncomfortable grievances as irrational noise rather than legitimate feedback. For a leader in a mental health trust, reducing the distress or anger of service users and critics to the behaviour of animals is a serious failure of empathy.
There is a fundamental difference between describing an action and pathologising a person's character. Saying that people are criticising your leadership is a statement of fact; claiming they "love to hate" you implies their internal motives are settled and beyond reason. This defensive posture allows you to bypass self-reflection at the exact moment a leader needs it most—during a period of organisational crisis or transition.
It is remarkably easy to practise person-centred thinking, extend compassion, and talk about the beauty of connection when you are on the receiving end of a warm embrace from someone you respect. But that is not the true test of the philosophy you champion. The genuine, agonising test of person-centred leadership is whether you can extend that same willingness to recognise complexity, humanity, and validity to people who are angry with you, who disagree with your decisions, or who openly welcome your departure.
Compassion and active listening become demanding precisely when the person in front of you is unsympathetic, critical, or hostile. Encountering public anger is undoubtedly uncomfortable, but an individual's emotional presentation should never settle the question of whether they have something legitimate to say. If your advocacy for recognising the person behind the circumstances is a core value rather than a rhetorical device, it must apply universally. The ultimate challenge of leadership is not just recognising humanity in those who offer you comfort, but retaining that recognition when your own ego and professional legacy are on the line.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete