The notion, there is no ‘truth
only perception’, is usually attributed to the French author Gustave Flaubert.
The German philosopher Nietzsche held the view that there is no such thing as
truth; there can only be perspective and interpretation, most often guided by
an individual’s interests. The process of interpreting sensory information is what
we call perception. Whereas perspective is the broader lens, shaped by experience,
beliefs and culture, through which we interpret information.
Both concepts are interconnected. My perspective on, and perceptions of the world and how I experience it, determine what is true for me. The same works for others too. Their perspectives and perceptions determine what is true for them. I keep this thought in mind when trying to practice unconditional positive regard for others. I know there are some people who simply can’t be persuaded that the truth they believe in is false. Once I had someone who felt my being a nurse was untrue. This was despite my many years of clinical practice, nurse management and nursing academia. As a result of their persistent claim that I had never been a nurse, they judged me unfit for public service. Such an assertion caused trouble. Thankfully such people are few and far between.
Flaubert was the son of a famous French surgeon. I’m sure that his childhood experiences will have influenced his writing of his most famous novel, ‘Madame Bovary’. In its day (1856), his book was said to be salacious in nature and both Flaubert, and his publisher were charged with immorality. Both were acquitted and the book became a bestseller. Although it would be judged tame by today’s standards, it is still a good read.I was reminded of the story by a
discussion I had last week with mental health Chairs from across England. We
were discussing where the future mental health workforce might come from. At my
mental health Trust, recruiting experienced mental health nurses, psychiatrists
and other members of the multi-professional team can be a real challenge. As a
group, we concluded that the future mental health workforce is likely to evolve
into something very different from the more traditional workforce we have now.
This is not a new thought.
In Flaubert’s book, one of the main
characters, Charles Bovary, studies at medical school. He doesn’t succeed and fails
to become a qualified doctor. However, back then it was possible to become a ‘Officer
de sante’ in the public health system. In this role they could practice medicine,
without being able to use the title Doctor of Medicine. After his first wife
dies, Charles meets and eventually marries Emma. She is the Madame Bovary
in the book’s title. Unlike Charles, Emma wants to climb the social ladder and
is fuelled in this ambition by her desire for wealth, influence and passion.
Emma eventually kills herself, but not before she has enjoyed (sic) over many
years, a succession of affairs and lovers.
The reason Charles was able to
practice medicine was in part due to a catastrophic shortage of doctors in
France at that time; a consequence of the French Revolution and severe economic
conditions. Like today, back then it took many years to train and educate
medical students, and so the ‘second order of doctors’ was formed. These
were the Officers de sante. They only studied medicine for three years
and/or had a slightly longer ‘apprenticeship’ with a fully qualified
doctor before they could practice. In the period of scarcity, around 1790, they
filled the dreadful lack of medically-qualified practitioners. However, in 1803,
their role became unrecognised, Being either a surgeon or physician meant
holding a formal medical qualification. That said, in more recent times, 2023, the
idea of reviving the concept of a ‘second order doctor’ was once again
raised in France. The idea didn’t get actioned. I suggest we watch this space.
Back in the UK, we have a much
greater range of health care professionals who practice health care at all
levels of service provision. I’m sure that, in the future, the range of health
care professionals will continue to increase. Digital technology and AI are
already showing us how this might be possible. What we need to do now however,
is to create great places for people to work in, find better ways of retaining colleagues
and most importantly, look after their wellbeing.
*In our house we often treat
ourselves to a chicken kiev. As I’m a long-time vegetarian, these are made from
plant-based proteins, which we affectionally refer to as ‘chicken not chicken
kievs’

An interesting read, particularly the historical discussion of Flaubert and the officiers de santé. I enjoyed that aspect of the post, as well as the connection you draw between the historical development of healthcare roles and the challenges facing the contemporary workforce.
ReplyDeleteYour opening reflections on truth and perception also prompted me to consider a few philosophical perspectives. I have always been particularly drawn to Kierkegaard’s conception of subjective truth, although I would distinguish this from the suggestion that truth is simply whatever an individual happens to perceive it to be. For Kierkegaard, the relationship between the individual and truth is as significant as the objective content of what is known. There is, after all, a considerable difference between intellectually recognising a proposition and genuinely appropriating it in the way one lives.
Kant offers another interesting perspective. For him, the reality we experience is neither simply an objective world passively received by the mind nor an entirely subjective construction. Rather, experience emerges through the interaction between an external reality, as it affects our senses, and the cognitive structures through which the mind organises and makes sense of it. Our understanding is therefore necessarily conditioned by the very faculties through which we encounter the world. We can know reality as it appears to us, but never entirely as it might exist independently of our experience. Wordsworth captures something of this in Tintern Abbey, when he reflects upon the world of eye and ear, and what they “half create”. I have always rather liked that formulation. It acknowledges the creative contribution of the perceiver without losing sight of the world that is being perceived.
Heidegger’s distinction between Dasein and Mitsein adds a further dimension. We are not isolated subjects who subsequently encounter other people; our existence is fundamentally relational. Our understanding of ourselves and the world is, to a considerable extent, shaped through our being-with others. This makes me wonder whether our encounters with different perspectives are important not simply because they help us understand other people, but because they can also deepen our understanding of ourselves and the world we share. Another person’s interpretation need not necessarily be identical to our own, or even entirely correct, to offer something valuable to our understanding.
This brings me back to your reference to unconditional positive regard. I wonder whether there is an interesting connection here between the philosophical limits of our own understanding and the aspirations of person-centred practice. If our experience of the world is necessarily mediated by our own assumptions, histories and perspectives, then perhaps one of the most valuable things we can offer another person is a genuine willingness to understand their experience from within their own frame of reference, while remaining open to what it might teach us.
In that respect, unconditional positive regard seems to me to extend beyond benevolence or a willingness to accept difference. It involves a particular quality of attention: being able to take another person’s experience seriously without feeling that understanding necessarily requires agreement. It also allows us to recognise that our own interpretations, however sincerely held, remain open to refinement.
Perhaps this is one of the most interesting aspects of person-centredness: the recognition that understanding is not simply something we offer to others, but something that can develop through our encounters with them. If our perspectives are inevitably partial, then genuine dialogue offers an opportunity not only to understand another person’s world, but occasionally to discover something about our own that we might otherwise have overlooked. And perhaps that willingness to subject our own assumptions to the same scrutiny we apply to those of others is an important part of the process.
There’s something quite ironic about bringing up Madame Bovary in a discussion about perception and reality, especially when your organisation has previously been criticised by the CQC for its leadership being out of touch with what’s actually happening on the frontline.
ReplyDelete