Sunday 10 November 2019

Choices, Consequences and Recognition (with apologies to Karl Popper)


I don’t do politics in my blog posts, but it’s hard to read the news at present without being swamped by endless election promises and propaganda. I don’t know about you, but the constant so-called political analysis, claim and counter claim, the character assassinations are becoming extremely tiresome and depressing. In fact in this house, we are totally fed up with with what is going on. Sadly, it appears whatever the choice people will make on the 12th December, we might still end up with a very divided society. And then there is the weather. Many people last week had their lives turned upside down and inside out by the weather. Some parts of the UK had a month’s rain in just one day and flooding was the almost inevitable consequence.

Listening to the news and seeing the pictures of those areas affected was heart-breaking. Whilst thankfully it has never happened to me, it did to my best friend and the disruptive consequences lasted for years. During last week, the devastation of past floods was re-played and reasons sought for why there appears to be an increase in flooding. A number of people were trapped in a large shopping centre in Rotherham. It is a sprawling building built on a flood plain, and it’s almost inevitable that if we keep making planning choices like this, we will keep reaping the destructive consequences of our decisions. The most often heard reason for these floods was global warming and climate change, and what we were doing (or no not doing) that was having such an impact on our weather.  

Amidst all this debate came the announcement from Collins Dictionary that the word of the year was ‘climate strike’ – (which I think is actually two words if we are using strict Scrabble rules). Apparently, the term was first used four years ago to describe pupils refusing to attend school in protest over global warming. It is a term most often associated with the young Swedish environmental activist Greta Thurnberg. Last September she became the face of a world-wide series of demonstrations (involving 185 countries) protesting against the failure of governments to act on climate change. The Guardian newspaper, reporting on a huge mural being painted on the side of a building in San Francisco, yesterday described this remarkable young lady better than I could: ‘At the age of 16, Thunberg has already reached the exalted status of Nobel peace prize nominee, leader of a movement to reclaim the planet for future generations, focus of Donald Trump’s mockery, and hero among progressives and young people’ Now, not many of the politicians currently vying for our votes can be said to be worthy of such recognition.

As well as ‘climate strike’ (which does look like two words) the Collins Dictionary also recognised other terms including ‘non-binary’, indicating an individual’s preference not to be identified as a male or female; ‘double down’; ‘influencer’; ‘hopepunk’ (apparently a TV genre); and ‘deepfake’. Now you may recognise most of these words as well, but they are not something that I have heard crop up in conversation.  

Something else I didn’t recognise last week were the rationale behind the stories I read in Rolling Stone and the New York Times about someone called T.I. (real name Clifford Joseph Harris Jr.) who is a rapper, which allegedly is some kind of music genre, and not something around a chocolate bar. It appears he chose to accompany his 18-year-old daughter to her yearly health check-up. Now when I say accompany, this was not just driving his daughter to the GP’s surgery, this was actually being in the room as the consultation took place. I think this would have been outrageous enough, but it was revealed he was there to ascertain whether his daughter was still a virgin or not. Not surprisingly, his choice to do so, and talk about it, spiked a huge backlash on social media. I don’t intend to add to his daughter Deyjah’s probable trauma at this intrusion into her personal life, however she did use social media to ‘like’ comments that called her father’s actions ‘disgusting’, ‘possessive’ and ‘controlling’. Other commentators, those with real science behind their observations noted that there is no such thing as a so-called virginity test. Have a look at this excellent story  on the subject published in Friday’s Guardian newspaper (and there are other newspapers than this one – honest!). Personally, I think T.I. will come to regret the choices he made and the consequences that will follow.

And finally, my last story from last week comes from the weekly Death Audit we undertake at my hospital. We hold a belief that looking at deaths can teach us lots about medicine and the care provided to individuals. Carefully reviewing all death is as much about understanding the science of what has happened as it is about understanding the human condition. The week before last, a man in our hospital care died. Last week, his wife died with us. Grief isn’t an illness, but it can be more lethal than most of the illnesses treated by the good folk at the hospital. The so-called ‘Widowhood effect’, has been found to double the death rates in the three months following the death of a spouse. Men are more vulnerable than women. Clearly there is no health without mental health. We can’t always choose what happens to us, despite what others (including politicians) might tell us is the case. The consequences of the choices we make are not always predictable. Just as we should recognise that broken hearts aren’t just metaphoric, we should more readily accept that sometimes the consequences of our choices are not what we might have intended.


No comments:

Post a Comment