Sunday, 26 April 2026

The hidden voice of mental health unveiled

I had one of the best professors ever supervising my PhD, Joel Richman. Joel was a medical sociologist of great esteem. He was also an anthropologist, a disruptive academic, and at times a rascal*. He used his knowledge, talent and courage in a way that touched many people’s lives, mine included. He helped me embrace ethnography, as a way of observing the world. He gave me a different lens, with which I could try and make sense of the world. Joel really did leave me interested in observing people’s behaviour, what they say and at times, listening to what they are not saying.

Last week I was at the NHS North West System Leaders meeting. This was part of an NHS England Board regional tour. They are currently visiting each of the seven regions across England. All the Chief Executives and Chairs were invited to join the national team in exploring progress, ambitions, challenges and so on. It was also a chance for each of the three Integrated Care Systems in the North West to showcase how they were delivering the three ‘left shifts’ outlined in the NHS 10 Year Health Plan. In particular, how was ‘neighbourhood health care’ beginning to be developed and delivered.

I have to say the presentations from the national team were, for once, positive, congratulatory, and at times humorous. Unusually, there was an early nod towards mental health services. My colleague Anthony H from Pennine Care FT presented the work we had done together to eliminate ‘out of area placements’ over the past 18 months.

Out of area placements are used where service users requiring inpatient care can’t get this in Greater Manchester, as there are no available beds. They are then placed in services often many miles away from their home and family. It is a failure on our part that we used such placements. Eliminating these placements was a tremendous achievement on the part of my colleagues, and it was great to see their story being shared with colleagues from across the region and beyond.

Then, as is so often the case, the conversations returned to urgent and emergency care, and reducing waiting lists and waiting times. Mental health was put back in its box. Saying that, the local service presentations were interesting. The use of new technologies in transforming services was impressive, and the use of data to develop population health initiatives was encouraging, and in particular appeared to be really making a difference to preventing ill health and reducing the need for expensive hospital care.

But throughout the presentations there was no other mention of mental health. I wondered why - there is no health without mental health. One of the people who had been part of the Greater Manchester presentation was a GP called Claire. I grabbed her before she could leave and talked to her about when she thought her data programme might include mental health services. Her answer both surprised me and excited me.

She told me they are already looking at the related mental health problems that might result from the physical conditions their data had focused on. Anxiety, depression, generalised stress were all factors that they were now beginning to build into their data programme. Likewise, employment status, housing conditions, family and community, relationships were also increasingly recognised as being important health determinants and were now being incorporated into the data base.

Claire hadn’t mentioned any of these developments, and to be honest, I should have ‘heard’ what she didn’t say. But then, perhaps others wouldn’t have thought about the mental health and wellbeing consequences of Cardio Vascular Disease, Diabetes, Asthma and Chronic Kidney Disease either. Folk are probably more familiar with the physical consequences of such health problems. It was a lesson for me in terms of helping people think about mental health differently.

Travelling home on the train, I wondered what Joel would have made of my day. He sadly died on a plane, on his way back from a three-month speaking tour in Hong Kong in 2008. Health care, and how services are provided have changed out of all recognition since then. Thankfully, as was evident at the meeting last week, health care continues to transform, and hopefully for the better.  

 

*Joel once kept his Dean of Faculty a prisoner in his office as a protest at the termination of his contract. The police were called and he was arrested. After the Jewish Chronicle published his story, he was reinstated and carried on working for a number of years before his death in 2008.



No comments:

Post a Comment